Freuds Structure of Personality

The Structure of Personality (Freud)

Why do we act the way we do? Freud’s structure of personality offers a fascinating glimpse into the hidden forces shaping our behaviour. It is a cornerstone of his psychoanalytic theory, which breaks down the human psyche and provides a compelling framework for understanding the complex interplay of forces driving our actions and behaviours.

Sigmund Freud (1856-1939) was an Austrian neurologist and the founding father of psychoanalysis (Institute of Psychoanalysis). He developed many groundbreaking theories and models that have significantly influenced our understanding of the human mind. Freud’s work laid the foundation for modern psychology, and his insights continue to impact the field.

Freud proposed the structural model of personality in his 1923 work, The Ego and the Id (Freud Museum). It introduced the concept of the id, ego and superego, three components of the human psyche. This blog post will cover Freud’s structural model of personality and its relevance to understanding human behaviour.

What Is Freud’s Structure of Personality?

Freud’s structural model of personality proposed that personality consists of three interacting components: the id, ego and superego.

  • The id is the primal, unconscious part that seeks immediate gratification of basic drives and instincts.
  • The ego mediates between the id and the realities of the external world, helping navigate desires in a socially acceptable manner.
  • The superego embodies our internalised moral standards and societal values, acting as a moral compass that guides the ego to align actions with these ethical principles.

These three components develop at different points in our lives and interact to shape our behaviours, thoughts, and personalities. The id pushes for immediate pleasure, the superego imposes ethical constraints, and the ego tries to find a balance between the two.

Freud’s model has an important role in explaining behaviour, decision-making and internal conflict, for example:

Behaviour – the interaction between the id, ego and superego influence our actions and reactions. Behaviour is often a result of the ongoing conflict between the id’s desires, the ego’s rationality and the superego’s moral standards. For example:

  • Impulsive behaviour – when the id dominates, individuals may seek immediate pleasure without considering the consequences.
  • Moral behaviour – when the superego dominates, individuals may behave in a manner that aligns with moral, parental and societal standards and values.
  • Balanced behaviour – when the ego dominates, individuals may exhibit balanced and rational behaviour that considers both desires and rules.

Decision-making – the ego helps us to make more balanced and rational decisions, as it:

  • Operates on the reality principle.
  • Balances the id’s demands and the superego’s moralistic constraints, and aims to make realistic and socially acceptable choices.
  • Weighs the pros and cons, considers the consequences and ultimately chooses a course of action that satisfies both the id’s desires and the superego’s moral standards.
  • A well-functioning ego can effectively negotiate between the id and the superego, leading to decisions both practical and ethical.

Internal conflict – the id, ego and superego can constantly compete, which can cause internal conflict, for example:

  • A person can experience tension, guilt and anxiety when the id’s desires clash with the superego’s moral standards and the ego does not reconcile these struggles and resolve the conflict (Hopkins, 2019).
  • The ego employs defence mechanisms (e.g. repression, denial, projection and rationalisation) to manage conflicts and reduce anxiety and psychological distress. For example, an individual may repress desires deemed unacceptable by the superego. Understanding these internal conflicts can help address psychological issues and improve mental health.

Freud’s structural model provides a framework for understanding the complexities of human behaviour, the challenges of decision-making and the sources of internal conflict that shape our actions and choices.

What Is Freud’s Structural Model of Personality

The Three Components of Personality

The fundamental concept of Freud’s theory is that the personality is tripartite and can be divided into three components: the id, ego and superego.

The id (the primitive and instinctual self)

  • According to Freud, the id is the original and most primitive part of our personality and is present from birth.
  • It is crucial for our survival, especially for babies who will cry until an adult meets their needs.
  • It is completely unconscious and often irrational.
  • It includes instinctive and primitive impulses, e.g. sexuality, aggression, thirst and hunger. Freud called these “drives”.
  • It operates on the pleasure principle, which seeks immediate gratification of all basic desires and needs.
  • An example of the id is acting impulsively without considering consequences.

The ego (the rational self)

  • According to Freud, the ego develops around the age of two from the id.
  • It operates in the conscious, preconscious and unconscious mind.
  • It operates on the reality principle and aims to balance the id’s impulsive demands with the superego’s moralistic constraints.
  • It aims to meet the id’s desires in realistic and socially appropriate ways.
  • It functions as the mediator between the id and the external world, making decisions considering the reality of situations.
  • It employs defence mechanisms to reduce the tension between the id and the superego, thus balancing internal conflicts and adapting behaviour to fit social norms.
  • Think of it as the rational part of the psyche and a sensible adult.
  • An example of the ego in play is deciding to save money for a necessity instead of indulging in a luxury.

Superego (the moral conscience)

  • According to Freud, the superego develops around the age of five and operates on the morality principle.
  • It represents our sense of morality, ideals and norms acquired from parents and society.
  • It strives for perfection, provides us with guidelines and judges our actions.
  • It largely operates in the unconscious but also impacts the preconscious mind.
  • It encompasses two subsystems:
  • The conscience – includes things viewed as immoral by our parents and society, which makes us feel guilty for wrongdoings.
  • The ego ideal – represents our aspirations and how we ought to behave according to rules and standards. It makes us feel a sense of pride and self-worth.
  • An example of the superego is an individual feeling guilty for telling a lie.
  • Think of the superego as a disapproving parent or teacher.

Cherry (2024) has further information on the id, ego and superego in an article here. The Freud Museum London also has a video on its website here.

The Three Components of Personality

How the Components Interact

The id, ego and superego are not standalone components. They constantly interact to influence our behaviour, emotions and overall personality. The id drives primal desires and seeks immediate gratification, while the superego imposes moral values and societal standards. The ego acts as the rational mediator, balancing the id’s impulses with the superego’s restrictions.

The id and superego have different goals, often resulting in internal conflicts. The ego tries to resolve these conflicts by employing various defence mechanisms, such as repression, denial, projection or rationalisation, to find a realistic solution that satisfies the id and superego. It tries to find compromises that minimise internal conflict and allow effective functioning in the real world. Successful negotiation by the ego leads to balanced and adaptive behaviour and a healthy personality (Lumen Learning), while failure can result in anxiety, guilt or maladaptive behaviour.

Here are some examples of scenarios where these three components may clash:

Example 1

  • The id demands immediate pleasure without considering the reality, e.g. “I want to eat the whole cake”.
  • The superego might interject with moralistic feelings about indulgence and self-control, adding a layer of judgment to the ego’s decisions, e.g. “I should not eat the whole cake, it is unhealthy”.
  • The ego will negotiate a compromise that satisfies the id’s desire while considering the consequences, such as health and social norms, e.g. “Maybe I will have just a slice and be good for the rest of the day”.

Example 2

  • You have been saving money for a long-term goal, but you come across a luxurious holiday for sale. It is where you have always wanted to go, but it is expensive.
  • The id urges you to spend all of your savings on the holiday, seeking the excitement and pleasure of going away,
  • The superego reminds you of your long-term goal and the importance of financial responsibility, making you feel guilty for wanting to spend all of your savings.
  • The ego tries to find a balance and suggests evaluating your budget to see if there is a way to afford the holiday without jeopardising your savings goal. It might also propose setting aside a small monthly amount for such expenses.

Example 3

  • A friend makes a hurtful comment, and you feel a surge of anger and the impulse to retaliate harshly.
  • The id pushes you to respond aggressively, seeking immediate release of your anger.
  • The superego reminds you of the importance of maintaining friendships and handling conflicts with maturity, making you feel guilty for wanting to lash out.
  • The ego intervenes by suggesting you take a moment to calm down before responding. It encourages you to express your feelings calmly and constructively, addressing the issue without damaging the friendship.

The balance between these components is important. If one becomes dominant, it can lead to psychological issues. For example:

  • If the id is overactive, an individual may exhibit impulsive behaviours.
  • If the superego is overpowering, it can cause an individual to feel excessive guilt and anxiety.
  • If the ego is weak, an individual may have difficulty effectively balancing the demands of the id and superego.
How the Components Interact

Defence Mechanisms

Defence mechanisms are the ego’s tools for managing internal conflict and reducing stress and anxiety. They help protect the mind from feelings of distress and unacceptable thoughts or impulses. These mechanisms are part of the broader framework of psychoanalytic theory, which suggests that much of human behaviour is influenced by unconscious processes.

Some key defence mechanisms include:

  • Repression – pushing unwanted thoughts, feelings, memories or desires into the unconscious mind and keeping them out of conscious awareness, so the individual does not have to confront or deal with them directly. It is a way to avoid dealing with painful, disturbing or distressing content. For example, not remembering a traumatic event because of repressing the memory.
  • Denial – refusing to accept reality or facts and blocking external events that are painful or uncomfortable to avoid dealing with the emotional impacts.  For example, a person diagnosed with a terminal illness may deny the severity of their condition and continue to behave as if nothing is wrong, as it is too painful to face.
  • Projection – attributing one’s own unacceptable thoughts, feelings, impulses or motives to someone else, allowing individuals to externalise and distance themselves from these unwanted aspects of themselves. For example, someone feeling hostile might accuse others of being hostile towards them, projecting their feelings onto the other person.
  • Rationalisation – justifying actions or feelings by creating logical explanations, even if they are not the true reasons. By doing so, the individual avoids acknowledging the true motives or emotions behind their actions, which helps to make sense of behaviours or feelings that might otherwise be distressing. For example, a student who fails an exam may blame the difficulty on the questions or their teacher rather than their lack of preparation or effort.

These defence mechanisms:

  • Help the ego manage the tension between the id’s primal desires, the superego’s moral standards, and the demands of reality.
  • Enable the ego to protect itself from the stress and discomfort of internal conflicts and external pressures.
  • Protect our mental health by helping to maintain psychological stability by distorting or denying reality, thus reducing stress and anxiety.

It is important to note that overreliance on defence mechanisms and overuse can result in unhealthy patterns of behaviour and emotional distress and can hinder personal growth.

Freud’s daughter, Anna Freud, created ten major defence mechanisms, and Bailey & Pico (2023) have further details on this and some higher-level ones here.

Defence Mechanisms

Applications of Freud’s Model

Freud’s model has profoundly impacted our understanding of personality development, modern psychology and psychotherapy. 

Understanding personality development

According to Freud, personality occurs during various child development stages. The id, ego and superego play critical roles at different stages. The id is present from birth, the ego develops around the age of two, and the superego emerges around the age of five. The process is influenced by psychosexual stages in childhood: oral, anal, phallic, latency and genital (Cherry, 2023):

  • Oral stage (0-1 year) – the id focuses on oral pleasures such as sucking, chewing and biting. Fixation at this stage can lead to issues like dependency, aggression, and bad habits.
  • Anal stage (1-3 years) – the ego develops as children learn to control bodily functions. Fixation can result in either orderliness and rigidity or messiness and disorganisation.
  • Phallic stage (3-6 years) – the superego starts forming as children navigate the Oedipus (boys) or Electra (girls) complex, developing a sense of morality based on parental standards. Resolution leads to identification with the same-sex parent.
  • Latency stage (6-puberty) – the ego and superego continue to develop while sexual feelings are dormant. This stage is about developing skills and interests, with sexual energy being sublimated into other activities.
  • Genital stage (puberty onwards) – the mature personality emerges, balancing the id, ego and superego in a healthy way.

Influence on modern psychology and psychotherapy

Freud’s model has significantly influenced modern psychology and psychotherapy, for example:

  • It laid the foundation for psychodynamic theories, which focus on unconscious thoughts and feelings and early life experiences in shaping personality and behaviour.
  • It provided a foundation for new concepts and discoveries (Cherry, 2024).
  • Many therapeutic techniques, such as free association, dream analysis and transference are rooted in Freud’s theories. These techniques aim to uncover unconscious conflicts and help individuals gain insight into their behaviour and have become staples in many therapeutic settings. Various personality assessments are also based on or influenced by Freud’s theories.
  • It paved the way for modern talk therapies, emphasising the importance of exploring past experiences and unconscious processes in understanding and treating psychological issues.
  • It influenced subsequent theories of childhood development and personality formation through ideas on the stages of development.
  • Freud’s identification of defence mechanisms remains influential in understanding how individuals cope with stress, anxiety and conflict. Modern therapists often consider these mechanisms when working with clients.
  • It has indirectly influenced other therapeutic approaches, such as psychodynamic therapy, cognitive-behavioural therapy (CBT) and humanistic therapy.

Freud’s model in therapy

Therapists and counsellors can use it to understand clients’ internal conflicts and defence mechanisms and explore their early childhood experiences to understand current behaviour patterns that may be linked to unconscious drives.For example:

  • A therapist might explore how a client’s repressed childhood memories (repression) influence their current relationships or how projection is affecting their interactions with others.
  • A counsellor might look for unresolved issues from the phallic stage if a client has difficulty maintaining relationships.
  • A therapist might explore how unresolved conflicts between the id’s desires and the superego’s moral constraints are causing a client anxiety and panic attacks.
  • A counsellor’s client shows resistance to certain topics or therapeutic interventions, and the counsellor may view this as a defence mechanism, protecting the client from confronting painful unconscious material. By gently addressing the resistance, they can help the client uncover and process these hidden emotions.

Freud’s model in everyday life

It can help explain everyday behaviours, such as why someone might rationalise their actions to avoid guilt (rationalisation) or deny a distressing reality (denial). For example:

  • A worker attributes (projects) their own insecurities to how their colleagues behave.
  • An individual justifies (rationalises) staying in an unhealthy relationship by providing seemingly logical reasons.

Freud’s model can enhance our everyday lives in many ways, for example:

Self-awareness

Recognising the interactions between the id, ego, and superego can help us become more aware of our internal conflicts and find a healthy balance.

Emotional regulation

Understanding defence mechanisms can provide insight into why we might refuse to acknowledge certain feelings or experiences and how we might be unconsciously protecting ourselves from anxiety or stress. Recognising these mechanisms can empower us to address our emotions more directly and healthily.

Decision-making

Acknowledging the desires of the id and the moral guidance of the superego can help us make more balanced decisions.

Relationship insights

Understanding defence mechanisms and transference can help us recognise when we are projecting feelings from past relationships onto current ones. This awareness can improve communication and reduce misunderstandings with loved ones.

Managing stress

Knowing how the ego mediates between the id and superego can help us develop better coping strategies for stress, e.g. allowing ourselves small pleasures (id) while still meeting our responsibilities (superego), thus reducing overall stress.

Freud’s work has undeniably shaped how we understand human behaviour and mental processes. While some of his ideas have evolved, his contributions continue to be applicable in psychology, therapy and everyday life.

Applications of Freud’s Model

Criticisms and Limitations

While Freud’s model has been highly influential, it has received criticisms, and some common ones include:

  • Lack of empirical evidence – Freud’s model is based on case studies and clinical observations rather than rigorous scientific experiments, and his concepts of the id, ego, and superego are difficult to test and measure. Therefore, it is challenging to validate or refute his theories through scientific methods.
  • Overemphasis on unconscious drives and childhood – Freud is often accused of placing too much emphasis on unconscious sexual and aggressive drives, as well as early childhood experiences, in shaping personality and behaviour. Critics argue that this focus neglects the role of conscious thought processes and experiences, current life circumstances, and social and cultural influences. It can also be seen as reductive, ignoring the complexity and variability of human development.
  • Perceived gender and cultural biases -Freud’s theories have been criticised for reflecting the gender and cultural biases of his time. His perspectives on female sexuality and the development of women (e.g. the concept of “penis envy“) have been seen as sexist and reinforce outdated gender stereotypes. Also, his theories are based on Western, middle-class experiences, which may not be applicable to individuals from different cultural backgrounds.

Despite these criticisms, it is important to recognise Freud’s contributions within their historical context. His work pioneered the exploration of the human mind and introduced the idea that unconscious processes play a significant role in our behaviour – a concept that has been foundational to many subsequent psychological theories. Freud’s emphasis on the formative role of early experiences also opened new avenues for understanding personality development and has significantly influenced this area of psychology (Zhang, 2020).

Even today, Freud’s ideas continue to inspire discussions about personality dynamics. They offer a framework that, while not empirically flawless, still enriches our understanding of the complexities of human behaviour. Freud’s contributions have undeniably shaped the field of psychology in profound ways.

Why Freud’s Theory Still Matters

Freud’s theory still remains significant, as it laid the foundation for many modern psychological theories and therapeutic practices. Techniques like free association, dream analysis, and transference have evolved but remain central to psychoanalytic therapy.

Freud’s theory also introduced the concept of the unconscious mind to psychology; before him, the idea that much of our mental life occurs outside of conscious awareness was not widely accepted. He suggested that a significant part of our mental processes is unconscious and that unconscious thoughts and feelings influence our behaviours, emotions and mental health – a concept that has become a cornerstone of modern psychology. It changed our understanding of human behaviour, emphasising that unconscious desires and fears often drive our actions.

Understanding internal conflicts in mental health has ongoing relevance. Freud’s theory emphasised that internal conflicts, especially those rooted in early childhood experiences and unconscious drives, can significantly impact behaviour and mental health. Therapists and counsellors often explore clients’ internal conflicts to help them understand their behaviours and emotions better and help them address issues such as anxiety, depression and personality disorders.

Freud’s ideas may have evolved over time. However, his contributions remain vital to understanding human behaviour and mental health. His work has had a lasting impact on the field of psychology and in therapy and counselling (Freud Museum London).

Journal Psyche has some interesting points on whether Freud’s personality theory is still relevant here.

Why Freud’s Theory Still Matters

Conclusion

Freud’s structural model of personality consists of three interacting components. The id, the most primitive and unconscious part of our personality, seeks immediate gratification of basic drives and desires. The superego represents the internalised moral standards and ideals, striving for perfection and judging our actions based on these moral standards. The ego tries to balance the id’s desires and realities of the external world. The components of personality constantly interact and shape how we think and behave.

Although Freud’s model has limitations and received criticism, it has endured and is still significant today. It provides a foundational theory in psychology; it introduced the idea that human behaviour is because of complex interactions between these three components. Freud’s model emphasised that much of our mental life is unconscious, which was groundbreaking at the time. It also highlighted the importance of internal conflicts in shaping our personalities and behaviours.

The model has profoundly impacted our understanding of human behaviour, personality development and mental health. It has also influenced various therapeutic approaches, emphasising the importance of exploring unconscious conflicts and motivations.

Reflecting on our own internal conflicts can be incredibly insightful. Understanding how our id, ego and superego interact and managing them can help us cope with internal conflicts, strive for balance in our lives and improve our mental health. Consider moments when you have felt torn between immediate gratification and long-term goals or have wrestled with guilt or pride. How do you manage these internal conflicts? Reflecting on these questions can provide valuable insights into your personality and how you interact with the world.

Psychology and Counselling Courses

Looking to get a Mental Health qualification?

We offer a wide range of Counselling and Psychology courses all with full tutor support.

Learn more